
- A personal alarm lets someone call for help. A falls detector tries to call for help automatically when a fall is detected.
- No device catches every fall, and every device can produce false alarms. Understanding both is the key to choosing well.
- Who answers matters as much as what the device does: a monitoring centre, family, or a support worker.
- The best alarm is the one the person will actually wear and use, every day.
When someone has a fall, or when a family member worries they might, personal alarms are often the first idea. A button on a pendant. A watch that detects a fall. A sensor on the wall. They sound simple, and in the right situation they are lifesaving. But there is a gap between the marketing and the reality, and that gap is where people get disappointed, or worse, falsely reassured.
This guide explains how the main types work, what they can and cannot do and how to choose with open eyes.
Alarms and detectors support safety, but they do not prevent falls. If falls are a concern, speak with a doctor or occupational therapist about the underlying causes, including balance, medication, vision, footwear and the home environment.
The main types, side by side
| Type | How it works | Strengths | Limits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pendant or wristband with button | The person presses a button to call for help | Simple, no tech skills needed, can be worn in the shower if waterproof | Relies on the person being able and willing to press it, and wearing it |
| Pendant or watch with automatic falls detection | Sensors detect a sudden movement and impact, then alert | Can call for help if the person cannot press a button | Not every fall is detected, and some movements trigger false alarms |
| Wall or bedside button | A button fixed in a room, such as the bathroom or bedside | No need to wear anything, good for key risk spots | Only works where the button is, and the person has to reach it |
| Room sensors and radar | Detect presence, movement and sometimes falls in a room | Nothing to wear, can notice unusual patterns | Cost, setup, privacy considerations, and coverage limited to the room |
| Smartwatch features | Fall detection and emergency calling built into a smartwatch | Familiar device, many other features | Needs charging, a phone connection or mobile service, and the person must wear it |
| Voice-activated calling | Say a phrase to call someone through a smart speaker | Hands-free | Needs reliable speech, a working internet connection and the person to be near the speaker |
How automatic fall detection really works
Falls detection uses sensors to track movement. A device in a pendant or watch measures acceleration and orientation. A pattern that looks like a fall, such as a rapid drop followed by stillness, can trigger an alert, sometimes after a short delay to allow the person to cancel it. Some systems then call a monitoring centre or a set of contacts.
This is clever, but it is not magic. The algorithms have to guess whether a movement was a fall, a stumble, a drop of the device or a person sitting down heavily. Different brands and models have different strengths, and the results vary by person and by type of fall.
What detection tends to find hard
- Slow slides to the floor, as when someone sinks down gradually
- Falls onto soft surfaces, such as a bed or sofa
- Falls when the device is not worn, for example in the shower or at night
- Falls where the person lands in a position that the device does not read as a fall
What can cause false alarms
- Dropping or bumping the device
- Sitting down quickly or flopping onto a chair
- Exercise, reaching or bending
- Wearing the device loosely
A falls detector is a safety net with holes in it. A button the person presses is a net they control.
The question people forget: who answers?
An alarm is only as good as the response. When the button is pressed or a fall is detected, someone has to receive the alert and act. There are three common options.
A 24-hour service receives the alert, speaks to the person through the device if possible and contacts family, neighbours or emergency services. Monitoring is usually a subscription. Ask what happens at night, how long it takes to answer, and how contacts and emergency services are called.
The alert goes to a list of contacts by call or text. Cheaper, but depends on people being available and reachable at all hours. If nobody answers, what happens next?
In supported accommodation or when workers are present, alerts may go to a worker's phone or a nurse call system. Check the response times and who is responsible after hours.
A choosing guide: start with the person, not the product
- Understand the risk
Where and when does the person feel at risk: bathroom, bed, garden, night? What happened in the past? An OT can help map it.
- Check what the person can do
Can they press a button, speak, wear a pendant or watch, charge a device? Ability decides which type fits.
- Choose the response
Monitoring centre, family or workers. Check cost, coverage and how it handles the night.
- Decide where it is needed
Wearable, wall-mounted, or both. A pendant is useless in a drawer.
- Test it for real
A trial period, if offered, and a test of the whole chain: press, call, answer, action.
- Review regularly
Needs change. Batteries wear down. Contacts move. Set a regular review date.
Wearable or fixed? The wearable trap
The most common failure is simple: the person is not wearing it. They take it off to shower, to sleep, because it is uncomfortable or because it makes them feel unwell. A wearable that is on the bedside table when the fall happens is no use.
That is why fixed buttons in the highest-risk spots, such as the bathroom, bedside and toilet, are often worth adding. A fixed button in a place the person can always reach complements a wearable. For some people, a combination of both is best.
Privacy and dignity
Any device that detects or records movement raises questions about privacy. Think about these before you decide.
- Does the person agree to it, and understand what it does?
- What data does it collect, and who can see it?
- Does it include a camera or microphone, and if so, is that necessary?
- Does the person feel monitored or looked after?
The best outcome is a device the person chooses and feels is helpful. A device imposed on someone without agreement is more likely to be removed, ignored or resented.
Costs to ask about
- Upfront cost of the device and any installation
- Monthly monitoring fees, and what is included
- Contract length and cancellation terms
- Replacement batteries or charging costs
- Mobile or SIM costs for devices that use a mobile network
- What happens if the device is lost or damaged
Read the contract before you sign, especially for monitored services. Look for minimum terms, exit fees and how price rises are handled. See our guide on what to check in a contract.
Quick quiz: test your understanding
Dad has a falls-detecting pendant. He falls in the shower and the pendant is on his bedside table. What happens?
- The pendant still detects the fall
- Nothing, because the device was not on him
- The monitoring centre is alerted anyway
A wearable only works when it is worn. This is why fixed buttons in key spots, and a habit of wearing the device, matter. A waterproof pendant can be worn in the shower if the manufacturer says so.
Questions to ask the supplier
- How does the device detect a fall, and what are its known limits?
- Can it be worn in the shower, and is it waterproof?
- How long does the battery last, and how will the person know when it is low?
- Who receives the alert, and what happens if they do not answer?
- Does it work if the power or the internet is down?
- What are the contract terms, fees and cancellation rights?
- Can the person try it before committing?
Setting it up well
- The person has agreed to the device and understands how it works
- It is worn or placed where the person will have it when it is needed
- The person has practised pressing the button, and knows what happens next
- Contacts and phone numbers are correct and tested
- The battery plan is clear: charging schedule or replacement date
- The device has been tested end to end, including the response
- A fixed button is placed in the bathroom or bedside if needed
- Contract terms and costs are written down
- A review date is set for three months from now
What a fall plan looks like
An alarm is one part. A good plan covers what to do before, during and after a fall.
A good plan
- Reduce the risk: lighting, clear floors, rails, footwear and medication reviews
- Have a way to call for help that fits the person
- Know who responds, and how quickly
- Review after any fall to see what could change
Risky habits
- Rely on one device and nothing else
- Assume detection catches every fall
- Leave the device in a drawer
- Ignore the home environment
- Skip the review after an incident
Funding
Personal alarms may be covered as assistive technology in some cases. NDIS participants may be able to include an alarm in their plan where it relates to disability and meets the reasonable and necessary test. Older Australians assessed for Support at Home may be able to access one through the AT-HM scheme. Monitoring fees can be treated differently from the device, so check with your plan manager or provider. An OT's note on falls risk helps. See our guide to how home modifications and assistive technology are funded.
Myths and misunderstandings
"Falls detection means I do not need to press anything."
It may help when you cannot press, but it will not catch every fall. A button the person can press is still valuable.
"A smartwatch does the same thing as a medical alarm."
It can do part of it. Check battery life, whether it is worn at night and in the shower, and who receives the alert.
"An alarm will stop falls."
It does not prevent them. It helps get help sooner. Preventing falls takes assessment, home changes and good habits.
"Once it is installed, we are done."
Batteries, contacts, contracts and needs all change. Set a review date.
How we can help
We supply and install personal alarms, wall buttons and related technology, and we explain plainly what each can and cannot do. We can pair an alarm with night lighting, rails and other changes so the home itself carries some of the load. We are honest about limits: if a simpler option will do, we will say so. See our personal alarms and falls detection page or book a free site visit.
Your first week: a simple action plan
You do not have to do everything at once. This sequence keeps things moving without overwhelm.
- Step 1
Decide who should receive alerts.
- Step 2
Choose wearable, fixed button or both.
- Step 3
Check waterproofing, battery life and coverage.
- Step 4
Test the whole chain from press to response.
- Step 5
Write down what the person does after a fall.
- Step 6
Review every three months.
Plain-English glossary
- Pendant
- A button worn on a cord around the neck.
- Falls detection
- Sensors that try to detect a fall automatically.
- Monitoring centre
- A service that answers alerts around the clock.
- False alarm
- An alert when no help is needed.
What happens at a Nemco site visit
If you would like a second pair of eyes, we visit the home, listen to the person first and look at the spaces they actually use. We take measurements and photos, check access for tradespeople and talk through the options in plain language, including simpler or cheaper ones where they will do the job. You then receive a written, itemised quote that your therapist, plan manager or family can read and compare. There is no obligation to proceed, and we will tell you if something is outside what we do. We also explain what each step involves for the person living there, how long the work is likely to take, whether the home can be used while it happens, and who to call if something does not work as expected after handover.
What to have ready
- Any therapist or hospital letters, or the name of the person coordinating care
- Photos or a rough sketch of the rooms involved
- A list of the times of day the person finds things hardest
- Landlord, strata or owner details if the home is not owned
- Your funding pathway, if you know it, or the name of the plan manager
When to bring in a professional sooner
If the person has had a recent fall, a change in health, a hospital stay or a new diagnosis, or if you are unsure whether a change is safe, speak to an occupational therapist or doctor before making changes. A quick conversation early can save money and avoid doing the wrong thing.
Questions to talk through at home
- Will the person wear it in the shower and at night?
- Who answers, and how fast?
- What is the cost over the contract?
- What if the power or mobile network fails?
Last checked: November 2026. Rules, prices and program details change, so confirm with the source before you act. Device capabilities vary by brand and model. Confirm specifications and contract terms before buying.
Common questions
Can a falls detector be worn in the shower?
Only if the manufacturer states that it is waterproof for that use. Check before you rely on it.
Do falls detectors catch every fall?
No. Detection can miss slow falls and some falls onto soft surfaces, and it can give false alarms. Pair it with a button the person can press.
Do I need a monitoring service?
Not always. Family or support workers can receive alerts. A monitoring centre adds 24-hour cover but usually involves a fee.
What if the person does not want to wear it?
Talk about why. Comfort, appearance and dignity matter. A fixed button or a different style may suit better.
Is it covered by funding?
It may be, depending on the pathway and the assessed need. Ask your coordinator, provider or OT.